
Patrons sit beside a glowing light outside of Henny's. Photo by Leslie Truluck.
STONE HARBOR –– Loyal patrons of Henny’s Restaurant will face last call Nov. 30 as the restaurant closes its doors and retires its namesake.
Henny’s property was sold earlier this year to Dr. John Sprandio, who is building the Shelter Haven Resort, a combined hotel-restaurant-bar-spa on the Henny’s property and at the vacant lot, across Third Avenue, at the corner of the Shelter Haven Basin.
Fourth-generation owners, Steve and Gary Blum, cousins, have worked at the family business their entire lives.
“Since we were 13 years old we would help clean the kitchen,” Steve said.
Long hours of hard work and commitment to the family business became tradition as Henny’s evolved as part of the borough’s identity.
It all started with John and Louise Blum, who moved from Gloucester to Stone Harbor in 1931 and founded the original family restaurant. The restaurant was not named Henny’s until their son, Henny Blum Sr., was born.
The couple affectionately called the original 96th Street property the “Tent.” The restaurant was moved to its current location at 97th and Third Avenue in 1935.
According to Henny’s Web site, John was a renowned cook whose clam chowder and snapper soup recipes were pursued by an undisclosed major soup manufacturer.
His deviled crab and deviled clam recipes continue to be served at the restaurant.
Louise tended bar at the “Old Heidelburg” until she was over 70 years old.
After John died in 1941, Henny Sr., second generation and namesake of the establishment, took summers off from working for the Pennsylvania Railroad to run his mother’s business with his wife, Tillie.
Henny’s interior and exterior was renovated in the late 1940s and early 1950s with a refaced outside and a new bar with nautical décor.
In 1963, the third generation, Norman and Henny Blum Jr. assumed responsibility for their father’s business. They bought the adjacent property in 1964.
Henny’s success seems to be the result of its dedicated and talented personnel throughout the years.
George Johnson entertained customers at the keyboard for 23 years.
Bob Sullivan led the kitchen as head chef for over 30 years.
Bartender Tom Jones served drinks for 29 years and Paul Gilligan has served Henny’s customers since 1979.
Arlene McMonigle and Dot Doran worked behind the scenes in the kitchen for over 35 years. It seems employees knew they were a part of something special.
The final owners Steve and Gary took reign of the business in 1993 and expanded the dining room and added a take-out window in 2005.
Henny’s will celebrate 70 years of tradition Nov. 30 with a last call party from 1-9 p.m.
Open bar, buffet, and entertainment from the Seabillies band and karaoke with Johnny Petillo will be provided for a $30 donation to the Middle Township High School athletics program.
“Both mine and Gary’s sons are involved in Middle Township sports and they always seem to need money for something,” he said.
“We’ll get everyone together from the many years before we head out for the holidays,” Steve said.
“The time was right and the business environment has changed; we’ve talked about this for many years, it wasn’t a sudden decision,” Steve said.
Steve said he plans to keep active and spend time with family.
“We’ve been so busy, I’d like to be more family-oriented,” he said.
“I’ll miss the customers the most. I’ve been involved in the community for about 30 years and learned when certain people come to the shore at the same time every year. I got to know when to expect them. We’ve made thousands of friends.”
Steve said once Henny’s closes he is going to take time to consider his next move.
“I’m too young to retire so I’ll keep active and move on to a new chapter in life,” he said.
Steve said the Shelter Haven Resort would likely benefit the borough.
“(Sprandio) has got many good ideas for the town in the off-season through weddings and banquets. I know many merchants are anxious for the resort,” Steve said.
“We will miss it,” he said.
Contact Truluck at (609) 886-8600 ext. 24 or at: ltruluck @cmcherald.com.
Posts: 10 | Views: 326
Posts: 1 | Views: 115
Posts: 0 | Views: 3
Posts: 8 | Views: 380
Posts: 67 | Views: 2667
Posts: 1 | Views: 34
Comments (3)
We welcome your thoughts, stories and information related to this article.
Tue, 12/02/2008 - 1:18pm
to 11/21 1:03
You'll never see a rebirth of anything. There is no cure for the vinyl plague. No one with the desire and ability to open new eateries can afford to get on the ground floor of anything when land values are geared toward out of state billionaires.
Any idea how many t shirts, pizzas, or chicken caesar wraps you need to move to pay the lease on one of the shoeboxes in the Mall? Forget Wildwood, Stone Harbor is becomming ugly enough.
Places hire summer help from eatern europe because you can't get locals off their fat @## for $9 an hour.Skee ball and deep fryers aren't skilled labor, and shouldn't be counted on as a household supporting source of income.
Sat, 11/22/2008 - 2:41am
My husband and I will miss Henny's as it was always a sure bet to get a good meal, in a pleasant atmosphere with the BEST snapper soup. We visit Henny's at least 4 or more times a year.
We will miss the restaurant and the excellent food it is noted for. We have heard that sometime in the future, Henny's might come back on a smaller scale....is that possible?
Also, what will they be doing with their snapper soup recipe.
Thank you Henny's for the memories associated with our coming to your establishment.
Nancy and John Fallon
Fri, 11/21/2008 - 1:03pm
One of many to come. The dinosaurs are dying with the economy and people are cashing out. It will be interesting to see how many go this offseason in the Wildwoods and Cape May. Most of them deserve it because they have been hiring foreigners for years and not paying employees. I believe in about 2 years, we will see a rebirth of resorts, restaurants, and hospitality to the region. It needs it!